Profiles Employee Assessment Blog

Our Editorial Mission

executive team al rainaldi



Joseph "Bud" Haney
CEO


With the Workplace 101: Blog, it is our mission to help organizational leaders and HR professionals improve their performance and workforce productivity by better understanding the application and value of workplace assessments.

Join 12,656 others and subscribe now!

Subscribe via E-mail

Your email:
request-a-free-assessment

Now Accepting Guest Posts

3d409d95-1a40-43da-944f-1861efde64a1

Browse by Tag

Subscribe by Email

Your email:

Workplace 101: A Profiles Global Business Blog

Current Articles | RSS Feed RSS Feed

3 Leadership Benefits of Choosing Self-Compassion

  
  
  
 

Is failure part of your vocabulary? Leaders must accentuate the positive in driving their organizations toward success, but a mythical view of leadership could be holding you back. Focusing only on your strengths keeps you from effectively dealing with your weaknesses. Heidi Grant Halvorson, a blogger for Harvard Business Review, argues that self-compassion may be a more effective path to success than having a high self-esteem.

Leaders are people of action. They must act boldly and with confidence. Dr. Henry Mintzberg, an internationally renowned business and management researcher, discovered that this pressure means “managers often have to feign confidence.” Halvorson described a leader’s pursuit of organizational success more bluntly:  confidence makes you feel the need to believe “you are perfectly awesome” all the time. This fake it till you make it mentality leaves us afraid of making mistakes.

Feigning confidence can create an internal tension between self-esteem and reality. Halvorson advocates forgetting self-esteem in exchange for self-compassion. We should embrace our failures because “high self-esteem does not predict better performance or greater success.” Turns out, faking it doesn’t always result in making it.

Leaders with self-compassion take a holistic approach to evaluating their abilities. This allows them to embrace their humanity without lowering the bar for success.

How do leaders benefit from choosing self-compassion over self-esteem?

1. They take control of their weaknesses
Realistic, self-compassionate leaders gain control over their weaknesses. They recognize their faults and can use these mistakes as opportunities for growth. Always evaluating mistakes from a position of high self-esteem limits the potential for growth. Self-compassion helps us see where we have room to grow and the next opportunities for our success instead of operating with a blind and shallow confidence that excuses weaknesses.

2. They see leaders as humans, not heroes
Self-compassion lets us take back our humanity. We realize that to err is human, but we keep both failure and success from defining us. Success is often a result of the right people being in the right role at the right time. This takes a lot of pressure away from the need to excel at everything. Managers who accept their flaws can see not only what went wrong but why and how to fix it in the future.  A report by the Institute for Human Resources on Mintzberg’s leadership research concluded that we should view “leaders as everyday people, not heroes.” If leaders only inspire, then we have nothing concrete for which to aspire. Seeing the connections between leading and managing helps us clearly define what it means to be a leader.
Read more:  Managers as Leaders – a Different Perspective

3. They develop as leaders (and help others do the same)
We can use the principle of self-compassion both for success in our own careers and for developing future leaders. Staying in the real world shows us that leaders can come from anywhere. Instead of looking for superheroes, we can focus on finding the right person to fit each role. We might want a savior, but an attainable reality provides a more secure comfort. Leaders also have to remember they cannot be the savior for their office. This realistic approach can promote teamwork and developing leadership characteristic in all of your employees.

While leaders with high self-esteem know how to focus on what they do well, they have no way of dealing with their weaknesses. The high self-esteem approach is to simply ignore them. Self-compassion opens the door for leaders to handle weaknesses more effectively. It’s a realistic approach that lets us take control over our failures and grow as leaders.

How has embracing your weaknesses helped you as a leader? Share your stories with us on Facebook, Twitter or in the comments section below.

product-cp360


Tags: 

Comments

I once read a book about "leading with a limp" and it talks about how we lead knowing that we have frailty and faults and are human. I worked for a company for 10 years, fantastic company but one of their motttos was "fake it til you make it" and it was a very uncomfortable place to be. I can see using positive affirmations to create a positive outlook but actually allowing others to believe that you are successful or that you have achieved success when it is not the complete truth allows you to live in a very vulnerable position. It creates alot of room for self doubt. Thanks for this article it reminded me that I can lead and manage and allow my team to help me shine each and every day - I am not alone.
Posted @ Monday, October 08, 2012 9:22 AM by Victoria
Victoria, thanks for sharing your experience!
Posted @ Monday, October 08, 2012 1:30 PM by Sally Ann Moyer
What a wonderful article and message, Sally. After 25 years working for corporate organisations and seeing the many different styles and traits of leaders, including my own, I started a business in recent years based almost solely on this premise - the idea that leaders can 'make it till they fake it' is prevalent and very common...and to your point, most never really make it. It is no coincidence that the very first blog I ever wrote a few years ago was titled, 'Falling Into Leadership', covering a very similar theme. This issue is real and self-compassion and working from strengths are two very sound ways to at least start the journey to stop faking it. Thank you, Steve
Posted @ Monday, October 08, 2012 3:45 PM by Stev e
It's great to hear your insights from personal experience. Thanks for commenting, Steve.
Posted @ Monday, October 08, 2012 4:42 PM by Sally Ann Moyer
Post Comment
Name
 *
Email
 *
Website (optional)
Comment
 *

Allowed tags: <a> link, <b> bold, <i> italics